Ed Psy 399OL- Spring 2001
Dianne Fulton
Tom Anderson – Instructor
************************************************************
|
|
************************************************************
Lesson 1 Question 3
OL 399 Spring 2001
Instructor-Tom Anderson
Dianne Fulton
“Nothing in life is to be
feared. It is only to be understood.” Marie Curie
Explain a fear, phobia or some euphoric action of yours that seems to be linked to a typically “neutral” stimulus, like a color, a piece of clothing, place on the highway, seat in a car, or whatever. Do you remember any classical conditioning event from your past that might have created this type of response? Be sure to identify the UCS, UCR, CS and CR for your audience.
One insurmountable fear suffered by
this author is that of water, whether submersion, immersion, suffusion, or even
inundation. Suffering the greatest of
embarrassments as a result avoidance of any possible associated situations was
a strong pursuit throughout this life.
When sister Donna and yours truly
were ages 6 and 4 respectively, our mother took us to swimming lessons at the
local YWCA. These lessons transpired in
a large pool with several other little girls and one instructor. Parents could stay and observe on bleacher
seats at the sides.
At the start of the first lesson, the class entered
the water eager to listen and learn.
Almost immediately, mother frantically cried out, “Don’t put your head
in!” and “Don’t drown!”
Needless-to-say, not much swimming came about from
that first lesson. At the outset of the
second lesson, mom’s beleaguered outbursts of incredulous horror quashed any
success of learning how to swim. There
were no further lessons at the behest of the two small sisters. To this day, the thought of swimming,
boating, or any water activity causes immediate attacks of extreme panic. The shower in the master bathroom has a handheld
sprayer so direct control of the direction of the streaming water is easily
controlled and kept away from the face.
Only two exposures to mother’s
irrational behavior caused this tremendous fear to continue into and throughout
an adult life! This is a textbook
definition of classical conditioning.
As it began, the water (in the swimming pool) equates to the neutral
stimulus when not paired with other factors.
However, mother’s frantic screams of abject terror upon entry to the
water echoed through the pool. Her
screams signify the unconditioned stimulus.
Since the cries link to the water, water then becomes the conditioned
stimulus. The unreasonable screams and
cries elicited fear of loss of life or limb. That is, “I would drown if my face
went under water.”
This clearly is the unconditioned response. After only two exposures to the same
exaggerated situations, a deathly fear of water and drowning arose for
encasement in this being, possibly forever.
The heart rate increases automatically at the possibility of the face
immersing in water. The reflexive
response results in fear or dread (i.e. the conditioned response).
“I’ve developed a new
philosophy…I only dread one day at a time.” Charlie Brown.
Berk,
Laura. (1996). Infants, Children,
and Adolescents. 2nd Ed., Boston: Allyn and Bacon.
Charles,
C.M. (1999). Building Classroom
Discipline. New York: Addison Wesley Longman.
Websites:
Behaviorism as a Learning
Theory, course documents
Huitt,
W. and J. Hummel. The
Behavioral System, May, 1998.
Personal:
Discussion
with sister, January 18, 2001.
Lesson 2 Question 2
399OL
Spring
2001
Tom
Anderson- Instructor
Dianne
Fulton
What
is your reaction to my inquiry about the exclusion of assertive discipline from
the textbook?
This
elementary teacher completed her undergraduate degree in elementary education
at Illinois State University in 1968, and immediately started teaching at the
same school in which she gained her elementary education. It is unfathomable that an author of a
textbook would not discuss such a fundamental approach to classroom management
as Assertive Discipline (AD). Although,
no undergraduate classes about classroom management considered AD, District 186
indoctrinated all teachers with Canter’s AD procedures in the 1980’s. The district had mandatory after school workshops
in the early 80’s that strongly advocated and reinforced the AD concept. Since that initial implementation and
enforcement of the basic AD concept, repercussions from that style of
discipline occur in the District’s classrooms to date. Requirements for teachers’ submission of
discipline plans at the onset of each school year exact strict
enforcement. The plans must include all
rules decided by the class and the consequences remain clearly visible and
delineated on the classroom walls throughout the school year. Parents and students must sign an agreement
at the outset of the year.
There
is considerable value to this plan on many of its points. Students must understand why rules exist and
learn how to follow them by modeling and reteaching (Charles, 89). Another point of Canter’s ideals is
redirecting student’s misbehavior with “eye contact,” close proximity, and
words of praise. The Assertive
Discipline model includes suggestions for the “difficult” student. This axiom further suggests that the teacher
could display their concern and care on an individual basis, therefore,
increasing the likelihood of “reaching” such a student. Additionally, Canter’s AD maxim suggests
that teachers should be ready to enforce their discipline plan in a fair and
consistent manner.
After reading Charles’
Chapter 4 on Assertive Discipline (AD), a question arose concerning where the
error existed in such a program. If an
author refrains from discussing the AD program in his new textbooks for the
beginning teachers and classroom management, then one must assume there is a
better system, of which all of this School District is unaware. What could that be?
Immediately, research
and investigation into our text, Building Classroom Discipline began to
determine what major points exceeded Assertive Discipline. Much of the basis of Assertive Discipline
procedures are in place, but the wording of the verbiage is different. Jones’s directives (Chapter 5) help students
support their own self-control. He
suggests using incentives to achieve this phenomenon (109). He also suggests employing the general
concepts of eye contact, physical proximity, remaining calm…(110-111), the same
as AD.
Albert’s
“Cooperative Discipline” relates many of the same principles for achieving classroom
management. She suggests that students
will behave when they personally establish a “code of conduct” and decide what
is proper conduct in their classroom (133).
Again, a like principle as stated in Assertive Discipline.
The
main response of Carolyn Evertson to why AD was not included was that the
American Psychological Association has labeled AD as psychological
maltreatment. One of the main concerns
for educators is teaching students responsibility for their own actions. Assertive Discipline (correctly applied) has
incentives for positive behavior as well as consequences for uncorrected
misbehaviors. Students do not learn
that there are consequences for actions when they are no negative correlations for
misbehavior. Such concepts of basic values,
many times, not taught at home cannot carry through to the classroom. Teachers, therefore, must instill such a
system of intrinsic values to their students.
Two of the most important ones are empathy and respect towards other
individuals (Gabe).
The
Fairview Elementary (my current teaching post) principal’s personal library of
books about discipline contained Classroom Management for Elementary
Teachers by Carolyn Evertson, et.al.
The publication date of the book is 1988. A review of the text included several similarities to Canter’s AD
directions. Chapter entries include
“Choosing Rules and Procedures”, “Rewards and Penalties,” “Getting Off to a
Good Start”, and “maintaining Good Student Behavior.” In this last chapter Evertson says, ” . . .good classroom
management depends on very careful planning of the classroom’s organization,
rules, procedures, and initial activities.
You will need to be actively involved in maintaining student cooperation
and compliance with necessary classroom rules and procedures” (95). Anything about these directives sound
familiar?
Assertive
Discipline components appear in almost all other basic discipline plans, even
though redefined. To state that it is
inappropriate to include AD in a text because the highly suspect American
Psychological Association (APA) found problems with the procedures is an inept
attempt at disguising a blatant form of cheap marketing. In Evertson’s own admission, she gives much
credence to Emmer and Aussiker saying (paraphrased): teachers and administrators cannot accurately perceive improved
student behavior. The APA reference
that Evertson used dates January 1988.
Those aware know that the APA’s opinions change more rapidly than the
breeze in Kansas. The APA is the same
organization that last year questioned the need for fathers in a child’s life.
(Dr. Laura) Therefore, I have wondered at some of the validity of the APA.
I am in agreement with other class
members who endorse the principles of Assertive Discipline in the classroom.
Works
Cited:
Charles, C.M. (1999). Building Classroom Discipline. 6th Ed. New York: Longman.
Evertson, Carolyn,
Emmer, E., Clements, B., Sanford, J., Worsham, M. (1988). Classroom
Management for Elementary Teachers.
Engelwood Cliffs: Prentice-Hall.
Canter, Lee and Canter,
Marlene. (1985). Assertive Discipline for Parents. Toronto: Harper & Row.
Websites:
Commentary: Lesson 2 Assertive Discipline
Schoolwide and Classroom Discipline. Kathryn Cotton.
http://www.nwrel.org/scpd/sirs/5/cu9.html
http://www.drlaura.com/main/ Comments on APA were heard last year on her
radio broadcast
http://lrs.ed.uiuc.edu/students/sbarnett/edpsy399/assertivediscipline.html
http://lrs.ed.uiuc.edu/students/mickley/edpsy33/lesson2q2.htm
Personal:
Gabe, Janice LCSW, MAC, lecture presentation,
“Kids in Cultures of Change.” Jan. 11, 2001.
************************************************************
Lesson 3 Question 1
399OL
Spring 2001
By Dianne Fulton
Question:
What are some ways that you use punishment to control the actions of
students? Are those ways
effective? Are there other alternatives?
“Using aversive stimuli to control the actions of humans is traditional, diverse, and controversial, but above all, its use can be effective.” (Course Documents). Unfortunately, experience shows that some students respond only to the threat or use of punishment to control their behavior. During the course of this dissertation, a description of the current classroom management plan, the pros, and the cons of using punishment will ensue.
Armed with teaching experience
dating to the early 70’s, this author has witnessed numerous changes to the
techniques of discipline designed for the classroom. Some days, controlling the behaviors of students seems to require
more time than presenting effective instruction. Within one teaching day it may be necessary to be all three types
of teachers as defined by Canter (Charles 85.)
Although being proactively involved is the ideal, there are days that
may require a nonassertive response, a hostile response, as well as an
assertive response style to various situations (87.)
Following our district’s guidelines
at the onset of each school year, we teachers establish the rules appropriate
for the particular third grade class.
Discussions with the new class ascertain and set the rules that are
necessary to insure effective learning.
We guide the class to a consensus concerning the rules by demonstrating
their purpose. Students, parents, and
teachers sign a code of conduct contract that promises that a teacher will
teach, a student will learn, and parents will be supportive. We also establish our consequences for our classroom
rules. They consist of:
“Taking away a pleasant stimulus, the likelihood of
the action being repeated in a similar situation is decreased. This effect is called Punishment.” (Course
Documents.)
We
investigated a visual chart for students (to “move their marker”) and a
clipboard system with student’s names recording rule infractions. The checklist system is more effective for
the following reasons:
This teacher professes the proactive, preventive
approach to discipline. We exercise
extraordinary efforts for observing students purposes of praise and
encouragement when they follow the guidelines.
Special encouragements extend to those who require particular assistance
following the rules. Continuous
movement about the room and providing feedback with “looks” (teacher’s “ole
evil eye,” smiles, pats on the back, and thumbs up) is effective. The key to classroom discipline is fairness,
but this can be very difficult when Behavioral Disordered students are in the
same classroom. Great efforts to
establish contracts with these students seem the most effective means of
solving this particular problem. Third
graders tend keep a close watch on fairness.
Additionally, parental support is
absolutely necessary. Contacts to
parents start early in the year, so when called them about discipline problems,
trust is already in place. Furthermore,
a very successful plan for early elementary teachers includes sending home a
weekly behavior checklist for parental information purposes. This simple form indicates the number of
behavior checks a student has earned for the week. Included is a personal note to the particular parents for
monitoring their child’s behavior, the type of offenses, etc. The parents should sign and return the
forms, within the weekly “Home Pride Folders,” which include the student’s
weekly assignments.
There are some problems implementing
this discipline plan. Due to busing and
safety requirements, teachers may not keep students after school. Due to daily scheduling, the 3rd
grade has no formal recess periods allotted.
On occasion, we allow extemporaneous recess periods. However, without an aid, the students who
deserve time outs cannot be supervised separately, thereby defeating the
system. The period that is available
and somewhat effective is during the lunchtime recess. During adequate weather periods, the
students go out of doors during that period.
Stipulating time-outs, detentions, etc., during such periods is a very
effective form of paying off infractions of the rules. Regardless, this detracts from the 45
minutes available for a personal lunch and the substantial preparations for the
remainder of the day. So many of the times, one feels that we are punishing
ourselves. During inclement weather
(which is most of the winter) students remain in the classroom during the lunch
recess, so there is no place available to have a meaningful “time out.” The struggle with alternatives to this plan,
especially this winter, was non-productive.
It is more than evident from the
extensive experience of this educator that plans for the sound management of
discipline are essential for successful learning in all classrooms. Drugs and alcohol directly and indirectly
influence the students. Gang members have
already approached some of the third graders.
Many of their moms and dads have abdicated their parental
responsibilities and half of the class does not have phone numbers. It is essential to express this so that one
understands that I am not whining, nor am I winning.
Works Cited:
Charles, C.M.
(1999). Building Classroom Discipline. 6th Ed. New York: Longman.
Anderson, Tom. Course Documents.
Churchward, Budd. Techniques for
Better Classroom Discipline.
KNEA. Tips for Teachers.
Edpsy 399OL – Spring 2001
Dianne Fulton
Tom Anderson, Instructor
Lesson 3, Question 2
Punishment
still lingers in various forms in most school districts – so does corporal
punishment! Where? In what forms does it exist in your
district? What does research say about
the effects of punishment, and of corporal punishment? What do you say about the use of punishment?
Why?
“It is estimated that corporal punishment is
administered between 1 and 2 million times a year in schools in the United
States. Increasingly, states are
abolishing corporal punishment as a means of discipline, but statutes in some
states still allow school officials to use this form of discipline.” (APA) It is hard to believe in this day and age
only 27 state legislatures have abolished corporal punishment in schools. Corporal
punishment still exists throughout the world, even in the new millennium, but
its use is widely discouraged. Third
world countries in Africa are even trying to abolish this abuse of human
rights. (Guardian)
During this teacher’s days of elementary school, the male sixth grade teacher took the boys and even a few girls out into the hall to receive swats from a huge wooden paddle. Most of the students that remained in the classroom unblemished from the paddle felt some indignation and empathized with their “punished” classmates, especially when the punishment was unjust. At the outset of my teaching career in the 1970’s, corporal punishment remained at Fairview Elementary. One first grade teacher became quite notorious for applying the paddle. The selection, on this teacher’s part, of a different classroom management plan insured no spanking of students in the assigned classroom. None-the-less, some of the same students, after misbehaving outside of the classroom, experienced corporal punishment administered by the female principal. Since witnesses had to be present, the teacher suffered along with her students. The punishment occurred only after parents agreed by completing a particular form describing the means and rules for corporal punishment. Since the 1980’s, District 186 forbade the use of corporal punishment at any of the district schools, for any reason. However, an incident of pseudo-corporal punishment happened last year in the district. A supervisor and security officer (partly in jest) handcuffed a middle school student, who was “goofing off” on the playground, to a fence. Parental outrage by this incident was exactly that. Incidentally, the district administrators retaliated, insuring no other reoccurrence of a similar staff infraction.
Research absolutely discourages the
use of corporal punishment. The
American Academy of Pediatrics
states that corporal punishment may adversely affect a student’s self-image and
school achievement. Additionally,
corporal punishment may also contribute to disruptive and violent student
behavior (APA.) The American Academy of
Child and Adolescent Psychiatry believes that corporal punishment, “signals
(to) the child that a way to settle interpersonal conflicts is to use physical
force and inflict pain They continue to state that punitive punishment may also
contribute to disruptive and violent student behavior. (APA) Children will also fail to develop trusting,
secure relationships with adults and fail to evolve the necessary skills to
settle disputes or wield authority in less violent ways.” (alcorenv) Researchers Docking, Doyle, and Maurer and
Wallerstein, have found that:
· Even when it is successful at inhibiting
inappropriate behavior, corporal punishment still doesn’t foster appropriate
behavior.
· Corporal punishment is sometimes unintentionally
reinforcing, since it brings attention from adults and peers.
· Corporal punishment often creates resentment and
hostility, making good working relationships harder to create in the future.
· Corporal punishment is related to undesirable outcomes,
such as increased vandalism and dropping out.
The Religious Tolerance
Organization also has many arguments against spanking. There reasoning includes:
· It is ineffective. (It will stop the misbehavior
only momentarily).
· It can lead to abuse. (Spanking may be used often,
and corporal punishment will become the standard response that could be carried
through to adulthood, thus repeating the cycle.
· It can unintentionally cause serious physical
damage.
· It trains a child to use violence.
· Slapping or any other type of force used on the
buttocks is a sexual violation.
· Spanking lowers the IQ. (A study of 960 children
showed that those who were rarely or never spanked had an average IQ of 102,
whereas the frequently spanked children had an IQ of 98. It goes on to state that they believe that
parents who do not spank are forced to use more reasoning and explaining while
disciplining the child, thus the verbal parent-child interactions enhance the
child’s cognitive ability.
· Spanking creates fear in the child.
In addition to these moral and psychological against
using corporal punishment, there is also the argument and statistics that show
racial and gender bias. The documents from the U.
S. Department of Education, Office for Civil Rights, 1998 Elementary and
Secondary School Civil Rights Compliance Reports have listed the ten worst
states by percentage of students struck by educators. (Illinois was not on this
list!) An additional bar graph shows that there is a steady decline in the use
of corporal punishment from about 1.5 million in 1980 to 365,000 in 1999. This survey also points out the significant
disproportion of African American students subjected to physical punishment,
and the worsening of that disproportion. (U.S. Department of Education)
There
is a voluminous amount of documentation stating that corporal punishment is
unfathomable in the public school system.
This is not an alternative to classroom management. At best, it is a very poor tool. The research for this paper included
considering the merits of corporal punishment, which always indicated that
there are more effective means to discipline students. The effect of corporal punishment can damage
a student’s self-esteem and cause irreparable damage in the relationship
between student and teacher. Frankly,
there is over-sensitivity about this on the part of the teacher. “Violence begets violence” and the cycle may
continue with the student “getting even.”
Personal experiences with corporal punishment have always been very
negative. Although, there is no
argument offered on the part of this teacher towards total abolition of this
form of punishment from all school systems, there are other forms of punishment
that deserve even more attention.
Although, corporal punishment does not attribute to a student’s
learning, the insidious forms of punishment such as derogatory comments by
teachers that cause students to loose all motivation in particular subjects are
just as serious.
Works Cited
Academy
of Pediatrics Corporal Punishment in Schools (RE9754). Volume
106,
Number 02. August 2000, p. 343.
alcorenv Corporal Punishment in Schools. A Policy
Statement by the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry, June
1988.
Course Documents. http://www.nwrel.org/scpd/sirs/5/cu9.html
Guardian
Corporal Punishment Should be Abolished in Schools. 12-14-99.
Religious Tolerance
Organization The Case Against Corporal Punishment
U.
S. Department of Education, Office for Civil Rights, 1998 Elementary and
Secondary School Civil Rights Compliance Reports Our Ten Worst States.
Personal:
Fairview Elementary School,
Springfield, Illinois. 6th grade. 1960.
Edpsy 399OL – Spring 2001
Dianne Fulton
Tom Anderson – Instructor
Lesson 4 Question 4
*In
some ways Kounin’s model casts the teacher into an orchestra conductor’s
role. Discuss how this can be a
reasonable metaphor, and some places where the metaphor breaks down. Does this metaphor work well to explain your
teaching techniques? Design one that
might work better.
Orchestra conductors actively seek to maximize the
positive continuity of their charge while minimizing the negative aspect of a
diminishing bottom line. In a stretch,
this is comparable to teachers influencing elements in the classroom to achieve
positive learning situation. In
reality, Kounin’s metaphor fails by being overly simplistic in accordance with
today’s actualities. The members of a
symphony orchestra are highly motivated because their living comes from a
specific purpose-to produce entertaining music, to which many will listen and
probably purchase. The simple idea is
that melodious tunes sell. The
“orchestra members” of a classroom (the students) are not always in class to
learn. A musician’s chosen field is
orchestrated for a common goal including a shared love of music, but students
do not always realize or acknowledge that their main pursuit of a living is learning. Although, learning for the classroom student
may not immediately pay off in vast sums of money, it is the means by which
they can become a member of an orchestra, thereby obtaining those same vast
sums of money. The musician
demonstrates god-given talents and hard-earned skills amassed through years of
practice. Early elementary teachers are
the ones preparing the prospective orchestra members by showing them how to put
their instruments together, how to follow music, and how to play and connect the
basic notes. Therefore, they are more
of a conductor of students rather than musicians.
Kounin’s seven models of discipline
apply directly to the conductor metaphor.
As classmates Barnett and Trieger stated, the conductor’s “withitness”
is necessary for the orchestra’s performance.
A teacher with this quality will increase her student’s performance in
all academic areas. Smooth transitions
from one piece (each lesson) to the next make the overall results much more
melodious. The orchestra members all
know which piece and page is next, and students must learn the same smooth
transitions. Pupils must be alert
(accountable) for their learning, and the conductor is obliged to insure they
remain so. The district’s transition to
State Leaning Standards and Benchmarks is a step in this direction. The final model for preventing boredom by
providing variety to lessons compares to the variations and interpretations
applied to the music repeatedly played by the symphony. (Humboldt).
An observation of Kounin states,
“that teachers’ personality traits had little to do with classroom
control. In reference to teacher traits
such as friendliness, helpfulness, rapport, warmth, patience, and the like, he
declared that (contrary to popular opinion) such traits are of no value in
managing a classroom. Management, he
insisted, is a complicated technology consisting of specific techniques applied
at the appropriate times and in the appropriate manner so as to provide
learning experiences that are nonsatiating.” (Charles 42). This axiom is not applicable in all
situations. A true orchestra is not
just a sum of management techniques, and the conductor is a person who truly
loves music. Likewise, what makes an
effective teacher is more than the technique they employ. It is extremely disheartening to witness the
number of clinical evaluations that state nothing more than what works in an
average classroom. A classroom is
composed of individuals who display individual behaviors and individual
purposes. A teacher is obliged to deal
with individuals, on an individual basis.
A conductor deals with musicians making music. Comparing a teacher to a conductor is oversimplifying the
resemblance.
Since the onset of this class, experience
shows that modifications occur on this teachers part to several of the
classroom management techniques noted in our text and reading. Likewise, we implement several of Kounin’s
techniques. Employment of the “ripple
effect,” where one student is reprimanded, thus affecting other students’
behavior is appropriate in certain instances.
Use of this technique in minor behavior issues such as noisiness or
getting up without permission shows excellent results in most cases.
Several techniques of “withitness”
are necessary for teachers. “Selecting
the proper student for correction” (Charles 37) is definitely
advantageous. There is a preference for
the eyesight to be better than 20/20 when identifying the misbehaving
student. Another element, timing, is
necessary to insure that an incident does not get out of hand. A classroom example is insuring that pencil
sharpening does not delay a written assignment.
Other comparisons to Kounin’s work
are:
This emerges and abounds through good questioning
and the application of unrelenting classroom motivational techniques.
Silently signaling answers with hand signals is one procedure that is used during each class to insure each child is answering and thinking. Even if a student is incorrect and observes his neighbor signaling correctly, they learn the correct response without publicity. Teachers may call on specific students to explain answers correctly. Thumbs up or down for opinion/true/false questioning is easy to implement. Individual dry erase boards practicing math is a very effective tool. The teacher can easily sum up (no pun intended) the whole class’s understanding of concepts.
· Overlapping- “refers to attending to two or more issues at the same time” (40).
While conducting a small group, hand signals can redirect another student’s behavior or activities, such as a need to sharpen a pencil, get a drink, etc…
Another metaphor for teaching:
A metaphor that is certainly self-serving and descriptive is that teachers are gardeners. Each year a gardener prepares the soil for the new crop of seeds. The seeds will definitely be a mixed variety. The gardener needs to be aware of such rich diversity in seeds and the special care each kind needs. The gardener’s experience will help him know what problems to anticipate and how to prepare for them. Next, a gardener must plan to plant the seeds in a manner or design that they will not strangle or overcrowd neighboring plants, like and unlike species. The gardener’s tools (teaching techniques) must be sharp and in good repair. A good gardener is always on the lookout for weeds (undesirable behavior) and will first use preventative measures (classroom rules) to inhibit the unwanted growth. If a weed (problem) pops up, the gardener’s diligence will insure the weeds cannot get a foot-hold, keeping them from spreading and ruining or lessening the whole crop’s yield. Additionally, insects and pests (excess baggage that comes with students) will be controlled or eradicated to insure the best crop. A gardener will nurture his plants with sunlight (classroom management), fertilizer (knowledge), and water (methods) insuring the young seedlings will refrain from withering or dying out. An extremely necessary virtue of a gardener is patience. If a plant is not thriving, a good gardener will use whatever means necessary to bring the seedling to good health. Despite meticulous care, a few plants will come up a few pedals short of a bloom! It is the duty of a gardener to care for his plants in a way that will produce the highest yield so they will go on and produce new seeds for the next year.
Works Cited
Charles, C. M. Building Classroom Discipline. Sixth Edition. New York: Longman.
Classmates:
Barnett, Treiger, et.al, Edpsy390OL Spring, 2001
Course Documents. Commentary on Kounin:
http://www.humboldt.edu/~tha1/discip-options.html
Personal experience:
Teaching 2nd-5th
grades at Fairview Elementary School, Springfield, Illinois. 1972-present.
Edpsy 399OL – Spring 2001
Dianne
Fulton
Tom
Anderson – Instructor
Report
some testimonies when your short-term memory or that of your students appears
to be overloaded. What did you do about
it?
After
reading several colleagues remarks and examples of short-term memory overload,
the decision was to explore the personal and classroom manifestations of
overloading. Since the 50th
birthday recently passed, it was necessary to insure that the short-term memory
lapses were actually attributable to overload and not the forgetfulness of old
age!
Several
sources defined and explained how short-term memory works.
Bruning states,” Like sensory memory, short-term
memory is limited with respect to capacity and duration.” The text goes on to state Miller’s theory of
the memory system in that the brain can “hold no more than seven or so chunks
(meaningful units of information) in memory at one time” (Bruning 36-37.) In Understanding How You Learn, MacDonald
states that, “Short-term memory functions as the first active storage site in
your memory process. It is responsible
for processing information to make it understandable, meaningful, and
useable.” She also states, “ the
information disappears quickly from short-term memory. Information is held here for only about
twenty seconds. It is the kind of
memory you use when you look up a telephone number.” Considering all of the above, it becomes very apparent how
overloading affects short-term memory.
Additionally,
Goodhead clarifies the meaning of short-term memory in his paper, “The
Difference Between Short-Term and Long-Term Memory.”
|
Entry
of Information |
|
|
Short
Term Memory (STM) |
Long
Term Memory (LTM) |
|
Enters as a result of applying attention
to the stimulus, which has been momentarily (about a quarter of a second)
held in a visual or auditory sensory registry. |
1) If information in the STM is rehe |