Computer Resources Evaluation

Here is my evaluation of IT tools.  I have researched two student centered web sites, a CD-ROM, a teacher web site, and a laserdisc.

Zoom Dinosaurs - from Enchanted Learning
Zoom Dinosaurs is a comprehensive online hypertext book about dinosaurs.  The audience can be from Pre-K on.  A table of contents on the side is useful to quickly find  the desired topics, which are easily found.  With simple instructions from the teacher or guided questions, students can find information for their research.  The section on Classroom Activities is separated into grade levels: Pre-K to 2nd, 3rd and up.  There is information and support for reports, dioramas, puzzles, and down loadable pages for classroom activities.  In the "Dinosaur Fun" category, each student may vote for their favorite dinosaur and find a favorite joke.  This site is user friendly and students learn to use all categories quickly after initial training.
Rating:  (1 lowest, 5 highest)  4
 

The Weather Dude
This is an Internet site for kids, parents and teachers.  It is suggested for elementary students grades 3-5.  This site can be used to inform students about weather.  Some interesting items are "Meteorology A-Z".  It is an explanation of meteorological related vocabulary.  There is a section about "Weather Report" where one may observe a live video display of the weather in the area.  The best portion (in my opinion) is the "Favorite Weather" photos of all kinds of special weather such as tornadoes, hurricanes, etc.  A "Weather Quiz" can be used for higher level students to test their knowledge.  The "Bill Nye" link took too long to download on our school computer.  This site has a number of multimedia displays. Younger students will need immediate guidance going through the different links.
Rating: (1 lowest, 5 highest) 3

Animals and How They Grow-  CD-ROM from National Geographic Society
This CD-ROM is specifically for Apple based systems.  This CD-ROM comes in a kit that includes the CD, 5 booklets, teacher guide, and poster.  The Reading level is primary, and appropriate for 3rd grade.  The objective is to increase basic reading concepts, comprehension, language skills, and vocabulary/grammar. The books included are Mammals, Amphibians, Reptiles, Birds, and Insects.  All of these topics are included in the primary science curriculum.  The teacher may control the settings for reading, i.e. the speed and whether the whole book is read a sentence at a time or one word at a time.  The lessons are adaptable into Spanish.  Students can click on the picture or words, initiating audio identification.  To use this in a classroom, one must have headphones to avoid distracting the remainder of the classroom.  This CD has good topics but fails to maintain students attention.
Rating: (1 lowest, 5 highest)  2

Dinosaurs- Laserdisc  by the Smithsonian Laserdisc Collection
This laserdisc includes a plethora of information about dinosaurs.  Therefore, teachers must be selective when using it.  Some parts should not be used by the lower elementary grades, but some parts do correspond directly to what I am currently teaching.  The guidebook that accompanies the laserdisc is a necessity; one needs to know the code numbers to cue the appropriate paragraphs.  Even though a laserdisc contains much information, the hardware is too specific and expensive to be used except when  no other means fills the bill.  I have used this as a resource to our dinosaur unit.  Students need to be taught to use the remote to search for the answers to guided questions.  The system is best employed by a team of students.  After fifteen minutes the laserdisc looses the attention of students.  Because of its lack of impact and difficulty of operation the overall usefulness will depend upon the teacher.
Rating: (1 lowest, 5 highest)  2

Puzzlemaker - Educators tool on the Internet
This is an easy tool to provide a variety of puzzles to reinforce class vocabulary and concepts.  There are simple directions to follow, and it takes about 5-10 minutes to make a crossword or other type of puzzle.  Since you make the clues or add the content, its employment may enhance the specifics of what one teaches.  Some topics include:  Mazes, Word Search (for those days with a sub?), Criss Cross Puzzles (crosswords), Number Blocks, Math Squares, and several others.  I use the Criss Cross Puzzles to stress vocabulary in spelling, Social Studies, or any content area.  The size of the puzzles is adjustable and this site has many awards.
Rating:  (1 lowest, 5 highest)  4